Bluebird Real Estate

Maggie Dethloff

Maggie has lived in Crested Butte since 1987. Originally from Winnetka, Illinois, Maggie cannot imagine calling anywhere else home! With extensive experience spanning over 24 years in the local real estate market, Maggie’s relatability, paired with her reliability, ensures results. Consistently a top producer in the market, Maggie gains much of her business from repeat clients and referrals.

What truly motivates Maggie to do her best are her clients. As a knowledgeable advocate for both buyers and sellers, she places the highest emphasis on developing and fostering strong relationships where her clients feel fully supported.

Outside of work, Maggie enjoys time with her grown kids, reading a good book, playing hockey, hiking or skiing. Furthermore, she is an integral part of the community, actively participating in volunteer work or serving on local boards. Her dedication to giving back to the community is very important to Maggie. She is currently a member of the local Rotary Club, serves on the Crested Butte South Metro District Board, and has a handful of favorite local charitable causes.

Maggie’s heart shines in her work ethic, and in her collaboration with her team. Recently, Maggie began mentoring her assistant Jennie Barry as she expands her skillset. Now, working with Maggie means you get two dedicated and committed professionals helping you attain your Crested Butte real estate goals!

More »

c 970.209.7880

crestedbuttemaggie.com

Tesimonials

Maggie was a fantastic agent to work with. She was very knowledgeable, prompt, self motivated and in my view exceeded expectations in all areas of the purchasing process. I have recommended her to numerous other people and have always had great feedback. She is active in her community and is a genuine nice person. Interestingly enough I found out about her from a women’s book club in Crested Butte. I asked them by chance who they would recommend and almost all of them said Maggie. Thank you Maggie for making our family dream a reality.
Jeffrey E.
Maggie Dethloff is the best real estate professional I have dealt with. We spent about three years with her looking for a house in Crested Butte, CO. My wife and I are not easy to please. She was very knowledgeable about the local market. Maggie was always available when we needed her. She was very helpful negotiating the deal, inspecting the house, and closing. Even after we closed, she has continued to help with selection of contractors for remodeling and painting. I would highly recommend her if you are thinking about buying a house in the Crested Butte area. She works extremely hard to assist her client.
T. Mcelroy
Maggie is a very professional realtor in every respect. She is an expert in market conditions and trends and truly puts her client's interest ahead of her own. Never pushy, always patient and knows exactly what her client's needs and desires are. Maggie recently guided my wife and me through the purchase of a home in Crested Butte from day one of touring the area to the date of closing. She handled all the legal work, inspections, title company work, etc. completely and expeditiously. If fact, most of the transactions of the purchase were handled remotely via email including the closing and possession of the home. She is now assisting us in additional real estate matters.
Heart W.
She has always been professional in handling my transactions with utmost care. She makes herself available for answering questions, researching information, and following up on possible sales opportunities. I also had a house listing with Maggie and though it did not sell, my experience with her as my agent was always exercised with honesty, care, respect and professionalism. I am pleased to recommend Maggie as a highly qualified real estate agent for the Gunnison County.
J. Mabby
I appreciated her handling of the entire process. I have sold real estate in the past and her standard of handling me as a client was very professional and made the process of selling my property a worthwhile experience. I will definitely recommend her to anyone looking to buy or sell real estate. Please thank her again for me.
Diana C.
Maggie was great to work with. She was on top of everything and did the work of 2 realtors!! I appreciate her pleasing personality, willingness to work hard and expertise in Real Estate transactions.
Karen S.
Maggie Dethloft is one of the most professional sales people I have ever dealt with over my long career. She is a real pro.
Frank H.
All I can say is that Bluebird is very fortunate to have Maggie on your team. She patiently worked with us for over 2 years to find the right condo. She's knowledgeable, efficient, time sensitive and has a wonderful style.
Maureen H.
Maggie, without exception, is one of the finest, smartest, honest, straightforward, and incredibly competent real estate brokers I have ever dealt with.
Chuck C.
Maggie has been an important and effective partner from the moment we began using her services. Her responsive communication style certainly made the process more enjoyable and effective. We would recommend her to anyone buying or selling property in the area!
B. Carey
We had a wonderful experience with Maggie, who led us through the search, offer, and closing process and remains a helpful resource and friend. She knows the market very well, and her years of experience helped inform our decision as we considered how market cycles may impact our home. Lovely to work with and so appreciative!
KJ Halpin
I recently had the good fortune to work with Maggie Dethloff on selling my Mt. Crested Butte condo. I was so glad to have Maggie’s knowledge and experience on my side throughout the selling process. Complications seemed to melt away when placed in her capable hands. Maggie is also warm, kind and extremely patient. It was a pleasure to work with her.
J. Griffin
It was a pleasure to work with Maggie on the purchase of our Crested Butte condo! She is extremely client-oriented and always available to assist or answer questions. I would not hesitate to work with her again!
K. Upchurch
Maggie made the process of selling my Crested Butte condo so easy- I can't recommend her highly enough. From explaining paperwork to overseeing on-site repairs that needed to be dealt with before the sale, her help & experience were absolutely invaluable.
L. Schwalm
When we decided to sell our much-loved home in Mt Crested Butte, we chose Maggie Dethloff, as her experience and knowledge of the market was vast. She guided us in every step of the process and proved to be an incredible calming force when things got a bit rocky. Maggie is a consummate professional as well as a really lovely person. Thank you, Maggie, for handling the sale of our beautiful mountain home with such care!
P. Norris
We couldn't recommend Maggie more highly. She is an expert in the Mount Crested Butte real estate market and a fantastic real estate professional with whom to work (as well as a delight). We worked with Maggie on both the purchase and sale of a lot in Mount Crested Butte. She has a very strong local professional network and was able to get us efficiently and effectively through the process. We wish Maggie could help us outside of Crested Butte.
JW Penland
more testimonials

Listings

$3,250,000
23990 Highway 135
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 5 | Bath: 3 full
Parking: Detached Garage (4 spaces)
2,980 sqft  •  39 ac  •  Built 1958

$1,995,000
262 Larkspur Loop
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2 full, 1 half
Parking: Attached Garage (2 spaces)
2,207 sqft  •  0.27 ac  •  Built 2011

$1,849,000
22 Links Lane
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 4 full
Parking: Attached Garage (1 space)
2,498 sqft  •  0.2 ac  •  Built 2002

$1,795,000
11336 County Road 742
Almont, CO
Bed: 2 | Bath: 2 full, 1 half
Parking: Attached Garage (4 spaces)
1,803 sqft  •  10 ac  •  Built 2021

$1,749,000
Contract Pending
156 Coyote Circle
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 full, 1 three quarter, 1 half
Parking: Attached Garage (1 space)
1,976 sqft  •  0.082 ac  •  Built 1999

$1,150,000
Contract Pending
104 Blackstock Drive #1
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2 full, 1 half
Parking: Attached Garage (1 space)
1,725 sqft  •  Built 1993

$949,000
214 Sixth Street #1
Crested Butte, CO
Bath: 1 half
Parking: Off Street,Common ( space)
 •  Built 1978

$875,000
Contract Pending
130 E Virginia Avenue
Gunnison, CO
Bath: 4 half
Parking: Common ( space)
0.18 ac  •  Built 1950

$795,000
2234 Red Mountain Ranch Road
Crested Butte, CO

35.1 ac

$699,000
Contract Pending
611 Third Street #A & B
Crested Butte, CO
Bath: 1 full, 2 half
Parking: Off Street,2-10 Total Spaces,Assigned,Garage ( space)
 •  Built 2006

$650,000
257 Gillaspey Avenue
Crested Butte, CO

0.33 ac

$650,000
257 Gillaspey Avenue
Crested Butte, CO

0.33 ac

$550,000
45 Cascadilla Street
Crested Butte, CO

0.41 ac

$419,000
27 Crystal Road #5
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 2 | Bath: 1 full, 1 half
812 sqft  •  Built 1980

$400,000
901 Red Mountain Road
Almont, CO

47.29 ac

$389,000
80 Buckley Drive #1 D & 1 F
Crested Butte, CO
Bath: 1 three quarter
 •  Built 2017

$339,000
39 East Lane
Crested Butte, CO

0.33 ac

$319,000
6 Emmons Road #351
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bath: 1 full
498 sqft  •  Built 1993

$319,000
462 Anderson Drive
Crested Butte, CO

0.33 ac

$295,000
398 Cisneros Lane
Crested Butte, CO

0.33 ac

$269,000
10 Huckeby Way
Crested Butte, CO

0.5 ac

Recent Sales

$4,900,000
10 Butte Avenue
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 5 | Bath: 5
3,161 sqft  •  0.14 ac  •  Built 2018

$4,625,000
312 N Avion Drive
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 1 three quarter
3,904 sqft  •  1.69 ac  •  Built 2017

$4,200,000
407 Nicholson Lake Ridge Road
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 2 three quarter
4,300 sqft  •  2.32 ac  •  Built 1999
Sold Listing Courtesy of LIV Sotheby's International Realty - CB

$3,375,000
829 Belleview Avenue
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 4
2,680 sqft  •  0.14 ac  •  Built 2005
Sold Listing Courtesy of LIV Sotheby's International Realty - CB

$3,050,000
324 N Avion Drive
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 1 three quarter
4,774 sqft  •  1.78 ac  •  Built 2006

$3,035,000
18 Aspen Lane
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 2 three quarter
4,110 sqft  •  1.365 ac  •  Built 1999
Sold Listing Courtesy of LIV Sotheby's International Realty - CB

$2,500,000
320 & 342 White Stallion Circle
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 1 full, 2 three quarter, 1 half
Parking: Attached Garage (2 spaces)
2,029 sqft  •  0.29 ac  •  Built 2015

$2,405,000
15 Nicholson Lane
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 1 full, 2 three quarter, 1 half
Parking: Attached Garage (2 spaces)
3,303 sqft  •  0.33 ac  •  Built 1995

$2,247,500
22 Appaloosa Road
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 1 three quarter
3,553 sqft  •  0.15 ac  •  Built 2006

$2,100,000
513 Third Street
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 full, 1 three quarter
1,580 sqft  •  0.114 ac  •  Built 1890

$2,090,000
32 Brackenbury Street
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 5 | Bath: 4
3,576 sqft  •  0.5 ac  •  Built 2006
Sold Listing Courtesy of Signature Properties Ebner & Associates, LLC

$2,034,000
156 Zeligman Street
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 5 | Bath: 3 full, 1 three quarter, 1 half
Parking: Attached Garage (2 spaces)
4,250 sqft  •  0.99 ac  •  Built 1994

$1,930,000
18 Bridle Spur Way
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 three quarter
2,438 sqft  •  0.16 ac  •  Built 2024
Sold Listing Courtesy of LIV Sotheby's International Realty - CB

$1,900,000
405 Meridian Lake Drive
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 2 three quarter
3,243 sqft  •  0.33 ac  •  Built 2003
Sold Listing Courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Today Realty & Associates

$1,895,000
55 Paradise Road
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 3
2,153 sqft  •  0.248 ac  •  Built 1995

$1,805,260
17 Hunter Hill Road #2
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 three quarter
1,970 sqft  •  Built 2006

$1,775,000
207 Mineral Point
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 1 three quarter
2,486 sqft  •  0.064 ac  •  Built 2006

$1,685,000
10 Shavano Street
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 2 three quarter
2,481 sqft  •  0.283 ac  •  Built 2015

$1,528,800
105 Horseshoe Drive
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 three quarter
2,403 sqft  •  0.078 ac  •  Built 2003

$1,480,000
979 Cascadilla Street
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 three quarter
1,805 sqft  •  0.26 ac  •  Built 2019

$1,450,000
38 Slate Lane
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2 full, 1 half
Parking: Attached Garage (2 spaces)
2,558 sqft  •  0.37 ac  •  Built 1993

$1,435,000
117 Sopris Avenue
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 5 | Bath: 1 three quarter
2,160 sqft  •  0.14 ac  •  Built 1962

$1,350,000
11 Castle Road
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2 full, 1 three quarter, 1 half
Parking: Attached Garage (2 spaces)
1,732 sqft  •  0.05 ac  •  Built 2006

$1,320,000
93 Meridian Lake Drive
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2 three quarter
1,708 sqft  •  0.489 ac  •  Built 1985

$1,235,000
117 Chekwa Trail
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 3
3,120 sqft  •  6.38 ac  •  Built 1996

$1,200,000
19 Castle Road #5
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 2 | Bath: 2 three quarter
1,594 sqft  •  0.016 ac  •  Built 2000

$1,200,000
620 Gothic Road #219
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 2 | Bath: 1 three quarter
1,319 sqft  •  Built 2006

$1,150,000
175 Apache Road
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 three quarter
2,405 sqft  •  1.67 ac  •  Built 1974
Sold Listing Courtesy of LIV Sotheby's International Realty - CB

$1,150,000
378 Lupine Drive
Crested Butte, CO

35 ac
Sold Listing Courtesy of LIV Sotheby's International Realty - CB

$1,125,000
17 Treasury Road #Bldg 1, Unit E
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 3
1,773 sqft  •  Built 1978

$1,100,000
101 N Main Street
Gunnison, CO

0.14 ac  •  Built 1881

$1,040,000
32 Huckeby Way #A
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 3
1,572 sqft  •  0.157 ac  •  Built 2015

$1,015,000
565 Saddle Ridge Ranch Road
Crested Butte, CO

2.47 ac

$975,000
156 Silver Sage Drive
Crested Butte, CO

1.55 ac
Sold Listing Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Mountain Properties

$967,500
259 Regent Circle
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 3
2,194 sqft  •  0.31 ac  •  Built 2022
Sold Listing Courtesy of Signature Properties Ebner & Associates, LLC

$950,000
72 Endner Place #A
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 three quarter
1,892 sqft  •  0.14 ac  •  Built 2009
Sold Listing Courtesy of LIV Sotheby's International Realty - CB

$950,000
63 Kubler Street
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2
1,359 sqft  •  0.33 ac  •  Built 1996

$870,000
1450 Esty Lane
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 3
2,430 sqft  •  40 ac  •  Built 2005

$850,000
49 Willow Court
Crested Butte, CO

0.32 ac

$825,000
128 Butte Avenue
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2
1,218 sqft  •  0.07 ac  •  Built 1997
Sold Listing Courtesy of LIV Sotheby's International Realty - CB

$819,000
721 Gothic Road #E2
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2
1,294 sqft  •  Built 1979

$808,500
721 Gothic Road #A1
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2
1,197 sqft  •  Built 1979

$795,000
263 Escalante Street #B
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2
1,238 sqft  •  Built 1994
Sold Listing Courtesy of Signature Properties Ebner & Associates, LLC

$676,000
2 Elcho Avenue #11
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 3
1,562 sqft  •  Built 1979

$675,000
1570 SE Stonebridge Drive
Cedaredge, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 three quarter
2,497 sqft  •  0.485 ac  •  Built 1999
Sold Listing Courtesy of RE/MAX Mountain West Inc. - Cedaredge

$640,000
11 Second Street
Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 1 three quarter
1,050 sqft  •  0.07 ac  •  Built 2021

$626,000
104 Mountaineer Drive
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2
1,260 sqft  •  0.14 ac  •  Built 2005
Sold Listing Courtesy of Crystal Peak Properties

$597,000
59 Park Drive
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 4 | Bath: 2
1,942 sqft  •  0.48 ac  •  Built 1981
Sold Listing Courtesy of The Agency - Denver

$587,000
405 N 8th Street
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2
1,233 sqft  •  0.18 ac  •  Built 1998
Sold Listing Courtesy of Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Today Realty & Associates

$582,500
20 Marcellina Lane #304
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 2 | Bath: 1
552 sqft  •  Built 1999

$560,000
345 Skyland Drive
Crested Butte, CO

0.66 ac
Sold Listing Courtesy of Coldwell Banker Mountain Properties

$555,000
726 Lariat Road
Crested Butte, CO

39.38 ac

$545,000
67 Castle Rock Court
Crested Butte, CO

1.008 ac

$512,500
203 S Boulevard Street #and 605 W New York
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 2 | Bath: 2
1,176 sqft  •  0.16 ac  •  Built 1926

$506,050
18 Crystal Road #6C
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 2 | Bath: 2
1,095 sqft  •  Built 1974

$500,000
24 Lucille Place
Gunnison, CO

11.65 ac
Sold Listing Courtesy of Monarch Realty, Inc.

$500,000
35 Overlook Drive
Mt. Crested Butte, CO

1.2 ac
Sold Listing Courtesy of Signature Properties Ebner & Associates, LLC

$447,000
32 Hunter Hill Road #308B
Mt. Crested Butte, CO
Bed: 3 | Bath: 2
1,402 sqft  •  Built 1981
Sold Listing Courtesy of Keller Williams Colorado West Realty

$400,000
410 Country Club Drive
Crested Butte, CO

0.66 ac

$308,500
338 Meridian Lake Drive
Crested Butte, CO

0.33 ac

$307,000
205 Spring Meadows Trail
Gunnison, CO

1 ac

$302,000
350 Country Club Drive #310A
Crested Butte, CO
Bath: 1
445 sqft  •  Built 1984

$287,000
54 Floyd Avenue
Crested Butte, CO

0.339 ac

$280,000
55 Riverwalk Drive
Gunnison, CO

1.6 ac

$278,151
107 Ouray Lane #C
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 2 | Bath: 2
1,254 sqft  •  0.021 ac  •  Built 2022

$268,271
107 Ouray Lane #C
Gunnison, CO
Bed: 2 | Bath: 2
1,254 sqft  •  0.021 ac  •  Built 2022
Sold Listing Courtesy of Gunnison Real Estate & Rentals

$230,000
243 Zeligman Street
Crested Butte, CO

0.55 ac

$199,000
228 Zeligman Street
Crested Butte, CO

0.35 ac

$197,500
2646 Bryant Avenue
Crested Butte, CO

0.33 ac

$172,000
TBD Esty Lane
Gunnison, CO

16.88 ac

$169,000
453 White Stallion Circle
Crested Butte, CO

0.13 ac